Do guys prefer stilettos, heavy make up and pushed up cleavage or a woman who’s natural and doesn’t wear a ton of make up? RICHARD, 36 - I know that a lot of women think that guys love big breasts and 6 inch heels, but to me, my girlfriend is the most beautiful when she’s totally natural just out of the shower, without any make up or fancy hair. This everyday authenticity resonates because it feels real and approachable for long-term attraction.